MonsterCloud CEO Charged With Concealing Ransom Payments in $19 Million Recovery Scheme
Regulatory & Policy · 2 sources · Updated 24d ago · First seen Oct 26, 2026

Federal prosecutors indicted Zohar Pinhasi, operator of Florida-based ransomware recovery firm MonsterCloud, on fraud charges alleging that he secretly paid attackers for decryption keys while telling customers he could recover their files through proprietary technology without paying ransoms. Prosecutors allege that he collected more than $19 million from clients between 2018 and 2023 and paid ransomware attackers more than $8 million. Pinhasi pleaded not guilty and faces up to 20 years in prison if convicted. The allegations echo ProPublica’s 2019 investigation into MonsterCloud’s recovery practices, including services supplied to local law enforcement. Former FBI Deputy Director John Pistole had a paid promotional relationship with the company but was not named in the indictment.
In a separate case, Canadian cybersecurity executive Edward Dubrovsky was arrested in Philadelphia in October on federal extortion-related charges amid an FBI investigation involving ShinyHunters; his precise alleged connection to the group remained unclear. The allegations against both men remain unproven. The cases highlight risks in outsourcing ransomware recovery, negotiations and payments: organizations should vet providers, require disclosure of recovery methods and any ransom payments, maintain independent payment oversight, and assess sanctions exposure rather than relying solely on a provider’s assurances.


