Skip to main content
Mallory
← Back to News
privacy-surveillance-policyenforcement-actioncivil-society-sector-threatstate-sponsored-espionage

European Spyware Victims Face Legal Barriers Despite Landmark Greek Convictions

Regulatory & Policy · 2 sources · Updated 5d ago · First seen Apr 27, 2026

European Spyware Victims Face Legal Barriers Despite Landmark Greek Convictions

Victims of alleged government surveillance using Predator, Pegasus and Graphite across Europe continue to face secrecy, lengthy litigation and limited accountability. An Athens court convicted four executives linked to Intellexa, including founder Tal Dilian, in what IrpiMedia described as Europe’s first criminal conviction of its kind. Their sentences remain suspended pending appeal, and investigators have not identified who ordered the surveillance. Interviews with victims in Greece, Spain, Poland, Hungary and Italy documented obstacles to obtaining information and legal redress, with authorities frequently invoking national security.

The cases involve journalists, activists and political opponents. Citizen Lab analyses revealed in 2025 that Italian phone numbers were among the targets of spyware developed by Paragon Solutions, while a Polish parliamentary inquiry concluded in October 2026 that Pegasus had been purchased unlawfully and used against political opponents. Outside Greece, the cases covered have produced no criminal convictions. European Parliament recommendations for victim assistance and stronger oversight remain unimplemented, according to officials cited in the reporting. Victims and experts are calling for greater transparency, effective remedies and mechanisms to identify both surveillance operators and those who ordered the attacks.

What this changes for youSee the reporting duties and controls this puts on the clock.
Get the context
Event timeline

How this story unfolded

Events from the most recent confirmed update back to the earliest known activity.

18 events · 2019 – Oct 2026
  1. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Koukakis challenges closure and brings spyware case before European rights court

    Koukakis challenged the Greek Supreme Court prosecutor’s refusal to reopen the investigation and brought a case against Greece before the European Court of Human Rights.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  2. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Greek court records reveal overlap between Predator targets and intelligence surveillance

    Greek court records showed that nearly one-third of people targeted in 2020 and 2021 were also under Greek intelligence surveillance. Journalist Thanasis Koukakis suspected a connection, while Greek authorities denied using Predator.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  3. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Italian parliamentary oversight body rules three surveillance cases lawful

    Italy’s parliamentary oversight body ruled that the surveillance of Luca Casarini, Beppe Caccia and David Yambio was lawful.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  4. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Graphite spyware targets Italian humanitarian activists

    Mediterranea Saving Humans founders Luca Casarini and Beppe Caccia, along with activist David Yambio, were targeted with Paragon’s Graphite spyware. Italy’s government cited suspected facilitation of irregular immigration, while Casarini attributed the targeting to their evidence of migrant abuse in Libya and Tunisia.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  5. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Òmnium Cultural spyware case reopened on appeal

    The legal case involving Òmnium Cultural spyware victims was dismissed and subsequently reopened on appeal. The Spanish government was asked to declassify related documents.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  6. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Hungarian authorities block disclosure of intelligence information about Panyi

    Panyi learned that Hungary’s civilian intelligence agency held classified information about him. Authorities invoked national security to block further disclosure.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  7. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Brejza wins civil judgments against broadcaster over manipulated exchanges

    Brejza obtained civil judgments requiring the broadcaster to apologize and pay damages following its broadcasts of altered exchanges. Related criminal investigations remained ongoing.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  8. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Polish prosecutors find no grounds for investigation underlying Brejza surveillance

    Prosecutors in Gdansk found no grounds for an investigation into Brejza’s father, a mayor. Poland’s Central Anti-Corruption Bureau had requested surveillance of Brejza in connection with that investigation.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  9. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Krzysztof Brejza targeted with Pegasus during an election campaign

    Krzysztof Brejza’s phone was infected with Pegasus while he led an election campaign against Poland’s then-ruling Law and Justice party. Brejza said attackers accessed 85,000 messages and supplied manipulated exchanges that national television broadcast to discredit him.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  10. Reported Nov 12, 20265d ago

    Citizen Lab finds spyware infections among 65 Catalan independence figures

    Citizen Lab found that spyware had infected the phones of at least 65 people associated with the Catalan independence movement, including four Òmnium Cultural members. Most infections occurred between 2017 and 2020; the source does not date the finding.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  11. Oct 2026

    Polish parliamentary inquiry finds Pegasus purchase and political use unlawful

    A Polish parliamentary inquiry concluded that Pegasus had been purchased unlawfully and used against political opponents. The inquiry had been established after Donald Tusk took office.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  12. Apr 27, 20267mo ago

    Greece’s Supreme Court prosecutor refuses to reopen spyware investigation

    After an Athens court referred the Predator case for further investigation, Greece’s Supreme Court prosecutor refused to reopen it. Investigators had not identified who ordered the surveillance.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  13. Feb 26, 20269mo ago

    Athens court convicts four Intellexa-linked executives over Predator surveillance

    An Athens court convicted four executives linked to Intellexa, including founder Tal Dilian, of illegal computer access, data protection violations and telecommunications privacy offenses. Their prison sentences of up to eight years were suspended pending appeal; the judgment was described as Europe’s first conviction of its kind.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  14. 2025

    Citizen Lab identifies Italian numbers targeted with Paragon spyware

    Citizen Lab analyses identified Italian phone numbers among the targets of spyware developed by Paragon Solutions.

    Spied on by governments with Israeli spyware: in Europe, no one pays the price - IrpiMedia
  15. Jun 15, 20233y ago

    European Parliament adopts spyware oversight and victim-assistance recommendations

    The European Parliament adopted its PEGA inquiry recommendations, including a fund for victims’ legal costs and an independent laboratory providing legal assistance, technical support and forensic analysis. The recommendations also called for stronger safeguards, notification of surveillance targets and effective remedies.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  16. 2022

    Spain’s ombudsman confirms authorized surveillance of 18 independence supporters

    Spain’s ombudsman confirmed that intelligence services had legally monitored 18 members of the Catalan independence movement. Òmnium Cultural representative Elena Jiménez disputed that judicial authorization alone established the surveillance’s lawfulness.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
  17. 2021

    Forbidden Stories investigation exposes Pegasus targeting across Europe

    An international investigation coordinated by Forbidden Stories revealed that dozens of European activists, politicians and journalists had been targeted with NSO Group’s Pegasus spyware.

    Spied on by governments with Israeli spyware: in Europe, no one pays the price - IrpiMedia
  18. 2019

    Hungarian journalist Szabolcs Panyi monitored with Pegasus

    Forensic analyses by Amnesty International’s Security Lab and Citizen Lab found that investigative journalist Szabolcs Panyi was monitored with Pegasus for seven months in 2019. Approximately 100 megabytes of data were transferred to and from his phone.

    Predator, Pegasus and Graphite: Governments Accused of Spyware Abuse Face Little Accountability
Linked entities

Related entities

Vulnerabilities, threat actors, malware, products, organizations, and breaches Mallory has linked to this story.

Open in app →

Organizations

5 linked
Paragon SolutionsNSO GroupIntellexaCentral Anti-Corruption BureauÒmnium Cultural
Do you run this?See what this changes for your reporting obligations and which controls it puts on the clock.
Get the Regulatory Context
Mallory platform

See the full picture, correlated to your attack surface.

This page covers what’s public. Mallory adds the parts that aren’t: which of your assets are affected, which threat actors are using it right now, and what to deploy next.

Exposure mappingMap indicators from this story to your assets and identify affected systems in minutes.
Threat actor evidenceEvery observed campaign, victim, and pivot linked to actors named in this story.
Associated malwareMalware, exploits, and IOCs connected to the activity described here.
Detection signaturesYARA, Sigma, and Snort rules deployed to your SIEM as soon as they’re published.
Scheduled alertsGet matching new stories delivered to your team as they break, not the next morning.
AI threadsAsk questions about this story and take action on the answers.