ICE Confirms Paragon Spyware Use as U.S. Commercial Spyware Policy Faces Scrutiny
Regulatory & Policy · 8 sources · Updated 5mo ago · First seen Mar 13, 2026

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement confirmed to lawmakers that it bought and used Paragon Solutions spyware, including Graphite, in investigations tied to drug trafficking, fentanyl networks, and other organizations using encrypted communications. Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons said the deployment complied with constitutional requirements and the 2023 executive order restricting government use of commercial spyware, but House Democrats including Rep. Summer Lee said ICE had not provided enough documentation, safeguards, or oversight to justify such invasive surveillance. The disclosure followed the reactivation of ICE’s Paragon contract after an earlier suspension for review, and came amid wider controversy over reports linking Paragon spyware to targeting of journalists and activists.
The admission intensified concerns that U.S. policy may be softening toward the commercial spyware industry even as evidence mounts that these vendors are driving serious cyber abuse. Reporting and research cited growing alarm over the lifting of sanctions on Intellexa executives, new U.S.-linked ownership of NSO Group and Paragon, and the expanding role of brokers, resellers, and other intermediaries that help spyware vendors evade export controls and obscure supply chains. Analysts also noted that Google attributed more zero-day exploitation to commercial surveillance vendors than to traditional state-backed groups in 2025, while lawmakers pressed for briefings on federal spyware use and U.S. investment in firms long associated with abuses involving Pegasus, Predator, and related surveillance tools.


