Network operators on the NANOG mailing list said remotely triggered black hole (RTBH) routing remains widely used for DDoS response but is implemented inconsistently across providers, with limited documentation and no universal cross-network model. James Bensley launched surveys and a public repository to collect details on how RTBH is deployed, why operators choose it, and what security and observability tradeoffs they face, with the stated aim of informing operational guidance, a BCOP, or a possible RFC on filtering practices.
Participants said RTBH can be attractive because it is simple and can quickly protect other customers by dropping traffic to an attacked destination, especially for smaller operators, but critics warned that full blackholing reduces visibility and may prolong outages by making it harder to tell when an attack has ended. Operators discussed alternatives such as downgrading attack traffic into a scavenger QoS class to preserve observability and automate recovery, while also noting that BGP FlowSpec is not yet a practical industry-wide replacement because of uneven vendor support, rule-compression differences, TCAM limits, and limited acceptance by upstreams, peers, and IXPs; broader anti-spoofing measures such as uRPF were also highlighted as important for spoofed-traffic attacks.

See the reporting duties and controls this puts on the clock.
1 event from the most recent confirmed update back to the earliest known activity.
In the NANOG discussion, James Bensley says he launched a survey and a public repository to collect details on how remotely triggered black hole routing is implemented across networks. He also describes conducting a second survey on operator motivations, concerns, observability, and security considerations around RTBH.
See what this changes for your reporting obligations and which controls it puts on the clock.
23 references tracked. Mallory keeps watching after this page renders.
seclists.org
Open sourceseclists.org
Open sourceseclists.org
Open sourceseclists.org
Open sourceseclists.org
Open sourcedocs.google.com
Open sourceremotely-triggered-black-hole.github.io
Open sourcelists.nanog.org
Open sourceMap indicators from this story to your assets and identify affected systems in minutes.
Every observed campaign, victim, and pivot linked to actors named in this story.
Malware, exploits, and IOCs connected to the activity described here.
YARA, Sigma, and Snort rules deployed to your SIEM as soon as they’re published.
Get matching new stories delivered to your team as they break — not the next morning.
Ask questions about this story and take action on the answers.