COLDCARD Seed Generation Flaw Exposed Wallets to $38M Bitcoin Theft
Emerging Technology Risk · 19 sources · Updated 3mo ago · First seen Mar 1, 2021

A flaw in COLDCARD hardware wallet firmware made some recovery seeds predictable, and attackers used the weakness to steal about 594.48 BTC—roughly $38 million—from around 500 wallets in a coordinated sweep lasting about 25 minutes. Reporting tied the theft to wallets created on affected devices, with the losses spread across roughly 500 transactions in three blocks and most of the stolen funds—about 562 BTC—later consolidated into a single address. The targeted wallets were reportedly single-signature wallets holding more than 0.15 BTC each, and many had been dormant for years.
The weakness was traced to firmware logic that failed to properly use the device hardware random number generator and instead relied on a predictable fallback with a 32-bit reseed mechanism, reducing entropy in generated seeds. Coinkite said the issue affects Mk3 devices running firmware 4.0.1 and later, and also affects Mk4, Mk5, and Q devices that generated seeds before fixed firmware was released; the company urged users to update firmware, create entirely new seeds, and move funds because updating alone does not repair already weak seeds. Coinkite added that wallets protected with sufficient independent dice-roll entropy or a strong BIP-39 passphrase are better protected, while TAPSIGNER, SATSCARD, and OPENDIME are not affected.


