Skip to main content
Mallory
← Back to News
privacy-surveillance-policycybersecurity-regulation

Canada’s Bill C-22 Raises Encryption and Metadata Security Concerns

Regulatory & Policy · 2 sources · Updated 2d ago · First seen Nov 16, 2026

Canada’s Bill C-22 Raises Encryption and Metadata Security Concerns

Canada’s Senate national security committee is scheduled to hear from Signal, Meta and Tailscale on November 16 as it considers Bill C-22, the proposed Lawful Access Act. Part 2 would authorize confidential orders requiring providers to develop lawful-access capabilities and allow regulations mandating up to six months of metadata retention for core providers. The bill has not received royal assent, and its access-capability requirements are not in force.

Signal, Meta, Tailscale and civil liberties organizations warn that the proposals could undermine encryption, expand surveillance risks and create sensitive data repositories vulnerable to compromise. They cite Salt Typhoon’s breaches of US telecommunications interception systems as evidence of the risks associated with lawful-access infrastructure. The government says amendments protect encryption and prohibit mandated systemic vulnerabilities; critics argue that service-modification orders and remaining metadata provisions still present security and constitutional risks. For affected providers, the central issues are potential obligations to modify services and retain metadata, rather than an already-enforceable interception mandate.

What this changes for youSee the reporting duties and controls this puts on the clock.
Get the context
Event timeline

How this story unfolded

Events from the most recent confirmed update back to the earliest known activity.

18 events · 2024 – Oct 22, 2026
  1. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Senate committee schedules testimony from Meta, Signal and Tailscale

    The Senate national security committee scheduled representatives of Meta, Signal and Tailscale to testify on November 16, 2026, from 6 to 7 p.m. Eastern Time. The source describes the hearing as scheduled, not completed.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  2. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Intelligence review agency requests access to ministerial-order information

    The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency sought guaranteed prompt access to information about ministerial orders.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  3. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Privacy commissioner seeks narrower subscriber-information powers

    Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne sought narrower definitions of subscriber information and covered providers in Bill C-22.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  4. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Intelligence commissioner seeks proportionality requirement

    Intelligence Commissioner Simon Noël requested an explicit proportionality requirement for confidential ministerial orders under the proposed legislation.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  5. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Canadian Bar Association requests stronger encryption safeguards

    The Canadian Bar Association requested a broader systemic-vulnerability definition and an explicit prohibition on undermining encryption. It also warned that mass metadata retention would likely face a challenge under section 8 of Canada's Charter.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  6. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Tailscale threatens court challenge and possible relocation

    Tailscale CEO Avery Pennarun objected to mandatory standing surveillance readiness and warned that retention requirements could conflict with privacy laws. He said Tailscale would challenge the legislation if enacted as written and would likely relocate if those challenges failed.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  7. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Meta, Apple and Google warn about surveillance and encryption risks

    Meta representative Rachel Curran warned that Part 2 could conscript private companies into the government's surveillance apparatus. Apple and Google warned that the legislation could require capabilities that weaken encryption.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  8. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Signal calls for Part 2 to be discarded

    Signal representative Udbhav Tiwari urged lawmakers to discard Part 2, warning that key-sharing orders, metadata collection and retention, and targeted platform changes could fundamentally break Signal. Signal requested judicial authorization and independent technical review for security-related orders, and said it would leave a market rather than betray its users.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  9. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    Government defends encryption protections in Bill C-22

    Anandasangaree said the bill was not intended to breach encryption. An added provision states that providers cannot be compelled to decrypt data unless they supplied the encryption and hold the key.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  10. Reported Nov 16, 20262d ago

    House amendments narrow proposed metadata-retention requirements

    House amendments reduced the maximum mandated metadata-retention period from one year to six months and required the minister to consider a metadata category essential before mandating retention. The amended systemic-vulnerability definition included a carve-out for flaws exposing only a target's data.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  11. Oct 22, 202627d ago

    Bill C-22 advances to Senate national security committee

    Bill C-22 reached the Senate national security committee after second reading.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  12. Sep 2026

    Technology companies seek further amendments

    At least 20 technology companies and industry groups wrote to Canada's public safety and industry ministers seeking further amendments to Bill C-22.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  13. Jun 18, 20265mo ago

    House of Commons passes Bill C-22

    Bill C-22 passed the House of Commons, advancing the proposed lawful-access legislation to the Senate.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  14. Jun 2, 20266mo ago

    Citizen Lab and civil liberties group submit brief opposing Part 2

    Citizen Lab and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association submitted a brief opposing Part 2, citing Salt Typhoon's compromises as evidence of interception-system risks. They also cited testimony that the NSA found security flaws in every CALEA-compliant switch it tested.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  15. Mar 12, 20268mo ago

    Public safety minister introduces Bill C-22

    Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree introduced the Lawful Access Act, 2026, as a standalone replacement for the lawful-access provisions of Bill C-2. Its proposed Part 2 would authorize confidential orders requiring providers to develop lawful-access capabilities.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  16. Feb 2025

    Salt Typhoon-linked actors compromise Canadian telecom devices

    Actors linked to Salt Typhoon compromised three Canadian telecommunications network devices, according to Canadian and US authorities. Reporting identified exploitation of a Cisco software flaw rather than a breach of an interception system.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  17. Dec 2024

    US agencies recommend encrypted messaging

    CISA and FBI officials urged Americans to use end-to-end encrypted messaging. CISA specifically recommended Signal in guidance for highly targeted individuals.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
  18. 2024

    Reports reveal Salt Typhoon compromises of US wiretap systems

    Reports said the China-linked Salt Typhoon group compromised US telecommunications interception systems used for lawful-access requests and accessed call and text metadata belonging to more than one million users.

    Canada Bill C-22 Could Force Apps to Build Intercept Tools: Senate to Hear Signal, Meta Monday
Linked entities

Related entities

Vulnerabilities, threat actors, malware, products, organizations, and breaches Mallory has linked to this story.

Open in app →

Affected products

2 linked
TailscaleSignal

Organizations

4 linked
TailscaleMeta PlatformsSignal MessengerSenate of Canada Standing Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs
Do you run this?See what this changes for your reporting obligations and which controls it puts on the clock.
Get the Regulatory Context
Mallory platform

See the full picture, correlated to your attack surface.

This page covers what’s public. Mallory adds the parts that aren’t: which of your assets are affected, which threat actors are using it right now, and what to deploy next.

Exposure mappingMap indicators from this story to your assets and identify affected systems in minutes.
Threat actor evidenceEvery observed campaign, victim, and pivot linked to actors named in this story.
Associated malwareMalware, exploits, and IOCs connected to the activity described here.
Detection signaturesYARA, Sigma, and Snort rules deployed to your SIEM as soon as they’re published.
Scheduled alertsGet matching new stories delivered to your team as they break, not the next morning.
AI threadsAsk questions about this story and take action on the answers.