Canada’s Bill C-22 Sparks Industry Backlash Over Encryption and Metadata Access
Regulatory & Policy · 3 sources · Updated 5mo ago · First seen Jun 8, 2026

Canada’s proposed lawful access bill, Bill C-22, drew opposition from Signal, Apple, Google, Meta, NordVPN, DuckDuckGo, Windscribe, and Tailscale, which warned that the measure could force providers to weaken encryption, retain user metadata for up to one year, and build technical capabilities for government access. Critics said the bill’s use of secret ministerial orders and limited judicial oversight could undermine privacy commitments, raise compliance costs, and create new security weaknesses that malicious actors could exploit.
Canadian officials said the legislation is intended to modernize investigative powers and that amendments will clarify it is not meant to break encryption, but the government plans to preserve the one-year metadata retention requirement. Civil liberties groups and researchers including Citizen Lab and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association argued that the metadata retention and ministerial-order provisions should be removed entirely, warning that the proposal deepens the conflict between lawful access demands and the need to protect privacy, cybersecurity, and secure communications.


